Did judas go to heaven reddit I already acknowledged the scriptures don’t seem to suggest that Judas did go to heaven and the reader/author who could think he went to hell. Luke 23:34 KJV — Then said Jesus, Father, forgive them; for they know not what they do. The true story is larger than what men can understand. Jesus loved Judas. But God works good out of evil. Regarding Judas Jesus said that he was “a devil” (John 6:70), and a “son of perdition”—i. Matthew did not use metanoeo, which means a genuine change of mind and will, but metamelomai, which merely connotes regret or sorrow. The nature of some sins especially those committed by ideology while the Lord can forgive, the sinner can never ask for it. No, Judas did not go to heaven, neither has any one else. It really stuck with me and I have read and re-read the gospels in various translations, discussed it with pastors and one of my friends, who is in seminary now. St. Just like Ananias and Sapphira, whom it was said of them the same thing "Why has Satan filled thine heart?" Best way to know that this doesn't describe a Godly person. He was never saved and even though he was remorseful before he committed suicide he never repented. It would not make sense. A subreddit for Christians of all sorts. But he chose otherwise. Mar 3, 2022 · Here we see Jesus condemning Judas, but considering that Judas travelled with Jesus for nearly three years, we know He also gave Judas ample opportunity for salvation and repentance. r/god is for discussion of all things "God". Thomas Aquinas, St. ( John 17:12 ) The word "destruction," in this verse, is translated to "apōleias" in Greek, meaning "destruction, ruin, loss, perishing; eternal ruin. Judas was never boastful about "standing shoulder to shoulder" with Jesus and then abandoning him when it truly mattered. As with satan, Judas' falling is his own fault. Judas was not saved. If we have free will, we can sin, so Heaven cannot be without sin, and that logic also means it should be possible to get kicked out of Heaven if you piss off YHWH. I’ve been reading some books about these gospels, and I did observe that they have a slightly different Jesus, for example in the gospel of Judas, it is told that Judas was the only one among the disciples who really understood Jesus and that his betrayal was rather an act of loyalship towards Jesus, so that Jesus can be freed from the body and return to heaven. e. He asked him to do it, enough said. I have no idea whether or not a historical Judas existed, but speaking just to this point: Jesus says several times in the New Testament that all twelve of his apostles will be at his side on a glorious throne during the second coming - yet one of those twelve would go on to betray him, which means either Judas is intended to sit at Jesus' side anyway (highly unlikely) . I didn't say "most", but the phrase obviously means most go to hell. But his sins are grave that heaven can't be attained right away so he goes to purgatory instead. Peter and Paul. In regards to the idea that Jesus "handpicked" Judas as his disciple knowing full well what was going to happen, He did. The overwhelmingly common interpretation over time of such expressions is that Judas has been, is, and ever will be among the damned. VI. Judas was a disciple up until the very end, but little is said of him in the Bible until… Matthew 7:21-23 (NASB95) 21 “Not everyone who says to Me, ‘Lord, Lord,’ will enter the kingdom of heaven, but he who does the will of My Father who is in heaven will enter. So who knows. But Judas had missed the point and misunderstood Jesus' message. Long story short, my friend said that judas was predestined to betray Jesus. However, if Judas went to Heaven, it would show that none are truly so far gone that they cannot be redeemed. I think this is why Judas killed himself in the end. Here is the passage from Luke 22:21-22. John’s Gospel provides new information about Judas, in spite of being the last New Testament gospel written. The overthrown of Tarquinius the Proud was also providential, as the rape of Lucretia (also mentioned in Pd. Jesus calls Judas a devil in John 6. There was no greater example of repentance in the Bible. " Judas did not betray Jesus because he lost faith or was disillusioned, rather Judas was convinced of Jesus the Military Messiah rather than Jesus the God-Man creating the Kingdom of Heaven. He played a huge part in humanity being able to go to Heaven. Still all we have to go off of is 4 gospels chosen by someone in Egypt ignoring and Gnostic text and even those four cannot agree on what happened to Judas. Jesus didn't say "Few will directly enter heaven". But I've thought about this issue and wanted to share a few things. 66 votes, 324 comments. God did not force him to fall. Getting right with God is the issue. This is a question which I've been wondering for some time. My initial short response was that, I find it highly unlikely that Judas is in heaven, but only God knows for sure. If one goes to purgatory, he/she will still go to heaven. And unlike judas I think hitler couldn't even regret let alone repent. The resurrection of the dead has not yet occurred, nor has the white throne judgement covered in the book of Revelation, chapter 20. He said "Few will enter heaven". I think Judas was trying to edge Jesus into bringing down armies of angels to finally smite Rome. He is or will be in Hell, then Hell will be cast into the Lake of Fire. reReddit: Top posts of Jesus' sacrifice was for others while Judas' actions were selfish. com Judas Iscariot betrayed Jesus Christ and later acknowledged that he had spilled innocent blood and returned the Silver, Judas appeared to have repentance and repented but he mainly repented to himself out of guilt and shame, then hung himself which is self murder. They are chosen by God to be redeemed from the earth. He's the first one to declare Jesus' innocence. But if that true, why did he go to hell for… In the same token, God didn't force Judas to betray Jesus, but by the time he was told that he would betray Jesus, it was a foregone conclusion. In fact, in John 13:26 Jesus even named who would betray him. Judas did something far worse than the others did because while the others seemed to react out of fear (by saving their own skin when they could have instead spoken up on behalf of jesus), Judas knowingly planned to harm his once Judas embodied the ways of the world is trying to stoke Jesus to violence. Nov 1, 2010 · Matthew 26:47 (KJV) And while he yet spake, lo, Judas, one of the twelve, came, and with him a great multitude with swords and staves, from the chief Aug 27, 2024 · No, Judas did not go to heaven. Jesus didn't say it would have been better for Judas if he hadn't been born. r/AskReddit A chip A close button. 21) I don’t have a theological argument, but let me just say— the play “The Last Days of Judas Iscariot” is an excellent meditation on this. Samael allegedly sinned while in Heaven, he was kicked out for being too prideful, so that can only mean free will still exists in Heaven. "Judas did not understand". In certain schools of Christian thought, hell is not everlasting, but a more painful form of purgatory Mar 3, 2022 · There were 13 guests, the last being Judas Iscariot, shown at the mosaic's bottom receiving the bread that Jesus dipped (John 13:18-30). I think God wants us to stay living so we can help others. So Jesus said only few will go to both Heaven and Purgatory, because if you enter Purgatory, you'll go to Heaven. Sep 19, 2009 · Yes, God allowed Judas to be used "that scripture might be fulfilled. Here, Judas was the treasurer for Jesus and the apostles, with John 13:29 referring to him holding “the bag” and tasked with purchasing necessities or distributing alms to the poor. Reddit . In her view: Since God is all-knowing, and since He knows therefore who will go to Heaven and Hell, who will accept Jesus as their Lord and savior and who wouldn't, that means He knows the kind of person Judas was. I don't get your point. Apr 13, 2022 · We speak of Judas Iscariot, Our Lord’s betrayer. He is basically put on trial, and various characters make the case that he should be allowed to go to heaven, but in the end (SPOILER ALERT) he rejects the Lord’s own beckoning to come to heaven. But they are not the only people that will go to Heaven. 22 “Many will say to Me on that day, ‘Lord, Lord, did we not prophesy in Your name, and in Your name cast out demons, and in Your name perform many miracles?’ 23 I've always wondered what would have happened if Judas never betrayed Jesus. [25] Aug 27, 2024 · No, Judas did not go to heaven. Jesus says of Judas, "The Son of Man will go just as it is written about him, but woe to that man (Judas) by whom the Son of Man is betrayed! It would have been better for that man if he had not been born. Judas's remorse was not repentance of sin, as the King James version suggests. Judas was not just a poor pawn in a divine game of chess that God would win. And Judas didn’t actually believe in Jesus; he just had proximity to Jesus. This may be a silly question, but I had never thought about this before until today. But, their actions aren't on even footing. In his foreknowledge, God knew Judas would give himself to be used of Satan. The betrayal could only have been done by Judas. repentance is complete U-Turn. Can judas go to heaven? I don't think so. We exist to provide a safe haven for all followers of Jesus Christ to discuss God, Jesus, the Bible, and information relative to our beliefs, and to provide non-believers a place to ask questions about Christianity as explained in the scriptures, without fear of mockery or debasement. Regarding the other part, Judas and Pharaoh had only regret. All of the facts are the same. John 6:70, “Jesus answered them, ‘Did I Myself not choose you, the twelve, and yet one of you is a devil?‘ 71 Now He meant Judas the son of Simon Iscariot, for he, one of the twelve, was going to betray Him. the concept that judas was crucified instead is a muslim theory based on verse 4:157 in the quran (there are other theories too but this is the most popular one in modern muslim circles) that says jesus was not killed nor crucified, rather he was raised up to heaven, think like enoch or elijah is christian history. 8. That would be the most selfish thing to do. The first, according to the Church, is of course true. ' Had Judas repented in faith, he would have been accepted back. What is the Orthodox stance on Judas and what happened to him after his death? In another Coptic text, the Acts of Andrew and Paul, Judas' suicide is apparently a strategy to get to heaven by being in hell when Christ harrows it, and he nearly succeeds, yet the high officials of Amente (hell) intercede before Satan so that they might retain possession of just one soul, and Christ commands Michael to hand over Judas. Augustine, St. However, did he go to hell because he committed suicide? No, that wasn’t why. It is the heretical Calvinistic belief that God “predestines” certain people to go to hell by purposefully depriving them of grace. And I know that only Christians can go to heaven but I have a Jewish Freind who I care about and I don’t want him to go to he*l so I’m confused and conflicted and just looking for answers Edit: Its been over 2 years since i posted this im much more educated now. Those 144,000 are from the tribes of Israel only. 8M subscribers in the atheism community. Because in the New Testament, it says all people from all nations get a chance to repent and go to Heaven. So, did Judas go to Hell? It certainly seems that way. All topics related to atheism, agnosticism and… Jesus still even calls Judas "friend" after Judas betrays him with a kiss (Matthew 26:50). neb piyo wlvq cuwc zsvf vslg vreol ljx xomlr kfrpcqjv ntu fnbcwt hkzutt jpedk nkkaq